Should you address, or avoid, controversial issues, in your fiction?
I address them – always have.
And yet, I do avoid particular issues, at particular times. I actually can and do hold back, on occasions.
What is controversial, anyway?
How do you define “controversy”? What is taboo in some circles, is spoken about openly in others. And almost everything you could possibly write about, is guaranteed to offend someone out there.
But there are definitely topics which would be generally agreed to be controversial.
This post isn’t about giving examples of specific areas that might cause controversy. We could all make our own lists.
Being controversial for the sake of it?
Honestly, don’t go there. It can be hard enough to deal with the backlash when you feel deeply about an issue.
And authenticity matters. Deal with controversial issues that are important to you, rather than simply “being controversial”, which is the point at which you’re being offensive. It’s a question of being honest with yourself, about your own motivations.
That said, don’t put up and shut up.
History is full of examples of people standing up for what they truly believed in. Where would we be, if everyone kept quiet, and was afraid to express unpopular opinions, or discuss the subjects that were strictly “off limits”?
So, yes – controversy. It’s a fine line sometimes, but we often do need to cross that line, in our fiction. As well as in our blog posts and poetry.
I’ll continue to address what I need to address, in my own writing, and hope that my honest intentions will shine through.
I’m not always right, and I don’t pretend to be, but I have my point of view, and will express that, through my words. I encourage you to do the same.
Read my views on how mental health is generally approached in fiction – including how I personally address the subject.
And should your characters be using swear words? I’ve written a post about this specific subject, which might be of interest.
I was talking to another writer about this today and it is an interesting topic. Because, I feel as long as it is Authentic there is no subject that can’t be written on. Meaning, am I writing from my perspective on the topic and how it directly effects me. If I am writing about something to try and tell others how to live. The thing with writing fiction for me is it is a way to express sometimes painful and dark, controvresial ideas in a creative way. Allowing me to work out the controversy in my own mind. Like working a math problem with words.
It helps me learn to accept things on another level.
Thank you for sharing this great topic.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for commenting, Matthew. I totally relate to what you’re saying. I very much use writing to process and explore my own emotions, often in relation to dark and controversial subjects.
LikeLike
I completely agree here. As long as it’s authentic, it’s good. Just for it’s own sake though, no way.
It was hinted at in your post also, but I’d also add deal with the subject matter in a rational way. Even with a subject like pedophilia (which everyone should be against) if your writing comes off as ranting or some manifesto, you can lose readership.
GREAT post though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Precisely. Authenticity is very much the key. I think, with fiction in particular, it comes across as poor, to use your story purely as a vehicle. Ranting on social media or in blog posts can be annoying too, but somehow feels more honest. I definitely agree about taking a rational approach, even to sensitive subjects.
LikeLiked by 1 person
0 Pingbacks